Can I Sell My Car with an Open Insurance Claim?

Jeff Varcadipane

May 17, 2022

Can I Sell My Car with an Open Insurance Claim?

If your car has been damaged in a car accident that was caused by someone else’s negligence, you may feel the need to move forward by selling your vehicle prior to the insurance claim being finalized. The costs you’re experiencing can put an immense financial strain on you, and selling may seem like your best option. It is important to take careful stock of your exact situation before doing so. If you are facing a conundrum of this kind, our experienced New Jersey insurance attorneys can help make the right decision for you in your unique situation. 

Your Vehicle

If you own your vehicle outright – with no loan payments pending – your car is yours to sell at any time, and the fact that you have an auto insurance claim pending has no bearing on this fact. This said, however, selling your car before your car insurance claim is finalized can seriously complicate the claims process. Further, if you are still paying off a car loan, the responsibility for paying off that loan remains yours. 

Your Car Insurance Claim

The optimal time to sell your car is after all of the following have transpired:

  • The extent of your damage is determined.
  • The other driver’s negligence is determined. 
  • Your claim is finalized, and you have received your settlement or court award. 

Because your personal recovery and your financial recovery can both hinge on how your insurance claim is resolved, it is almost certainly in your best interest to hold off on selling your vehicle until the matter is closed. 

Your Car’s Value

If you sell your car before the insurance claim is finalized, it’s likely to be worth considerably less than it would be if you’d had it repaired. Even if this is not the case, however, the fact of the accident can reduce your car’s value. In terms of getting the best return on your car’s sale, waiting until your car insurance claim is finalized is generally the best path forward. 

The Insurance Company’s Stance

The insurance company is in the business of turning a profit, which translates to settling claims for as little as possible (although there are laws in place that require insurance companies to settle claims like yours in good faith). If you no longer own the car in question, it can significantly decrease the value of your claim because the insurance company no longer has anything to base the amount of damage to your car on. 

Further, your car could hold valuable information about the other driver’s fault in the accident that leaves you injured. All told, selling your car prior to your insurance claim being finalized can decrease your claim’s overall value, can complicate the claim’s process, and could affect whether your personal injury claim ultimately settles in your favor.

An Experienced New Jersey Car Accident Attorney Can Help

The New Jersey car accident attorneys at Varcadipane & Pinnisi, PC, have the experience and legal savvy to help guide your car accident claim toward its most advantageous outcome while helping you make the right decisions along the way. Learn more by giving us a call at 201-588-1500 or contacting us today.

 

Let Us Fight For You

Need Help? Contact us 24/7

Free Consultation img (800) 616-2916

New Jersey Personal Injury Lawyer

Request Your
Free Consultation

Schedule a free consultation with one of our experienced lawyers today by filling out the form below, or call us at (800) 616-2916

    • "The law firm lead by Mr. Varcadipane provided service that was first rate. From our first conversation, till the final settlement, this firm provided me a level of comfort and expertise which was second to none. I would surely recomm..."

      Bruce H. Client

    • "Dawn Pinnisi is a caring and responsible attorney who worked assiduously on my behalf. Highly recommend. "

      Michele A. Client

    • "To be successful in a matter involving a business dispute requires an attorney who not only knows the law but who has spent significant time in the courtroom dealing with complex business litigation. Varcadipane & Pinnisi is that..."

      Carlo R. Client

    • "Varcadipane & Pinnisi were successful in negotiating our claim. Professional and knowledgeable "

      E.C.M. Business Client

    • "They were outstanding in every way and I couldn’t be more pleased! "

      Ana R. Client

    • "I would like to start off by telling everyone at the firm how thankful I am for all who were involved in my case. I was always treated professionally, like family, kind, and considerate and with a friendly smile. Moreover, my experie..."

      Cheri C. Client

    • "Words can’t adequately express my gratitude to Dawn for taking on my medical malpractice case. At our first meeting Dawn had compassion for I went through and took the time to listen to everything I had to say. Throughout the e..."

      Rick P. Client

    • "Dawn Pinnisi was recommended to me from another lawyer. From the moment I spoke with her, I left it all in her hands. I live 2 hours away and I never had to go to her office! She settled my lawsuit so fast and for more that I ever ex..."

      Jennifer S. Client

    • "I would like to start off by telling everyone at the firm how thankful I am for all of you who were involved in my case. I was always treated professionally, with a friendly smile and greeting anytime I was at the office. Moreover, m..."

      Kenneth K. Client

    • "I have known Jeff Varcadipane for over 7 years, during which time he has advised me on several real estate and civil claims issues. Most recently, he assisted with my complicated real estate transaction in NYC. He was very responsive..."

      Andrew L. Client

    • "The best way to describe Dawn is if you are looking for a person that will go to bat for you, to fight for your cause, that puts in the energy, research, and effort that is required to get you the settlement that you deserve, then lo..."

      Charles D. Client

    • "Great law firm! Dawn Pinnisi is a great lawyer, very easy to work with, and got me a more than fair settlement on my case. Highly recommend this law firm. "

      Donna H. Client

    • "When forming my business, it was important that I started with the right structure. Jeff took the time to explain the pros and cons from a legal perspective and I was able to make a confident decision. Varcadipane & Pinnisi got m..."

      Richard L. Brandbliss

    • "The legal process is complicated and at times frustrating but Jeff has managed to translate this process so it is clear to me. He has been patient in walking me through this step by step. Jeff has been timely in providing me with upd..."

      I.S. Client

    • "Dawn is the best she won 2 cases for me for over $300,000. The first one was very difficult being that the company had no insurance, but Dawn handled it with such persistence and professionalism that we won. If you want a lawyer who ..."

      Anonymous Client

    • "I highly endorse this lawyer. Dawn is smart and personable. She is known to be a great litigator and she is extremely knowledgeable about the law as well as being fiercely defensive of her clients. I have attended many court appearan..."

      Peer Review Birth Injury Attorney

    • "I had the pleasure of working with Ms. Pinnisi for 14 years. She is one of the most outstanding attorneys with whom I have dealt. Ms. Pinnisi meticulously prepares and researches cases and advocates zealously on behalf of her clients..."

      Peer Review Personal Injury Attorney

    • "Dawn Pinnisi is a fantastic attorney with whom I have worked on numerous cases. Dawn is someone I am proud to call a friend. Over the years I have seen how personally invested she becomes in each of her cases, stopping at nothing to ..."

      Peer Review Car Accident Attorney

    • "Dawn really helped me out in a time of need after my accident. I wasn’t sure if I had a case or not but after my consultation, she gave me hope. I felt like I could trust her and she always returned my phone calls after reachin..."

      Anonymous Client

    • "I highly recommend Dawn Pinnisi for medical malpractice, car accident, and personal injury cases. Not only is she one of the most experienced attorneys in the field she’s an honest, trustworthy, and caring person in the litigat..."

      Peer Review Criminal Defense Attorney

    • "I had the pleasure of working with Ms. Pinnisi for 14 years. She is one of the most outstanding attorneys with whom I have dealt. Ms. Pinnisi meticulously prepares and researches cases and advocates zealously on behalf of her clients..."

      Peer Review Personal Injury Attorney

    From The Blog

    view more blog posts